Independent Car Reviews — Scored Out of 100

How We Score →
BMW M5 — photo 1
1 / 3
Performance Saloon2024

BMW M5

The super-saloon reinvented — now with a plug.

90/100

CarCheckr Score

Outstanding

M5 xDrive

Starting Price£142,000
Year2024
CategoryPerformance Saloon
Score90/100

Score Breakdown

Performance & Dynamics24/25
Value for Money16/20
Reliability & Quality17/20
Technology & Features20/20
Practicality & Comfort15/15
Total Score90/100

Pros & Cons

What We Love

  • 717bhp is genuinely staggering
  • Seats five in real comfort
  • Electric-only mode for urban driving
  • Best M5 dynamics in a generation

Watch Out For

  • Heavier than predecessors at 2.4 tonnes
  • Electric range is only 35 miles
  • Expensive to run on petrol alone

How to Buy This Car

Our recommendation on the best way to finance your purchase.

RecommendedFinance (PCP)

PCP is the smart choice. BMW's GFV on the M5 is competitive, and you can upgrade to the next generation when battery technology improves.

Advantages

  • Competitive BMW GFV
  • Upgrade at end of term
  • Spread the cost

Watch Out For

  • Interest adds to total cost
  • Mileage restrictions

This is our independent opinion based on the car's depreciation profile, reliability record, and typical finance rates. Always get personalised financial advice before committing.

Used Buying Guide

Buying a Used BMW M5

What to look for — and what to avoid — when buying this car on the used market.

What to look for

  • G90 generation is brand new — used examples will be rare and command near-new prices initially
  • F90 generation (2018–2024) offers the last pure-petrol M5 — increasingly sought after
  • Competition specification adds sharper suspension and carbon ceramic brake option
  • xDrive AWD makes the M5 genuinely usable year-round without compromise
  • Full BMW dealer service history is essential — M5 servicing is complex and expensive

Watch-outs

  • S63 V8 engine requires meticulous servicing — check oil change intervals have been followed
  • Carbon ceramic brakes (optional) are very expensive to replace — verify specification
  • Check for any remapping — common on M5s and can affect warranty and reliability
  • F90 M5 had some rod bearing concerns at high mileage — check service history carefully
  • Tyres are expensive and wear quickly — factor into running cost calculations

Our Verdict

The G90 M5 is a landmark car. BMW's first plug-in hybrid M5 produces 717bhp from a twin-turbo V8 and electric motor combination, yet still manages to feel like an M car should. The electric range is modest, but the performance is staggering — 0–62mph in 3.5 seconds from a car that seats five in genuine comfort.

How This Score Was Built

Every CarCheckr score combines multiple independent data sources, weighted by category.

Manufacturer Specs

Official performance & safety data

Owner Reports

Real-world reliability data from owners

Expert Testing

Independent road test results

Residual Values

Three-year depreciation data

Running Costs

Insurance, fuel & servicing costs

Safety Ratings

Euro NCAP crash test results

0/100

Outstanding

CarCheckr Score

Key Details

Make
BMW
Model
M5
Year
2024
Variant
M5 xDrive
Category
Performance Saloon
Price from
£142,000
Back to all reviews